SME 309 or SME 3009r?


I have both arms. My turntable is an Avid Sequel. My cartridge is a Benz LP. I want to rewire one of the arms, but don't know which would sound best. I currently have the 309 on the table so I know how that one performs. I've had the 3009r for quite sometime just sitting on a shelf. It's in terrific shape and the person who gave it to me, and has since passed away, thought it would outperform the 309. Does anyone have an informed opinion? Thanks.

128x128neptune123

pesky, I did not specifically ask for your comment on the comparison between Technics B500 and SME 3009.  I too have heard only one and not the other.  But "on paper" does count for something.  (B500 has superior bearings, if they are intact, a more advanced VTA adjustment method, and a more sophisticated anti-skate device.) Anyway, I was wondering whether anyone had actually heard both. As to the 3009R, what about the 3009/2 or /II? Is that version different from the 3009R? Again, according only to internet reading the 3009/2 is generally thought to be superior to the base model.  I wouldn't argue for a minute that there is no substitute for direct experience, but when many listeners make similar comments on a particular audio component, it begins to add up to a significant factor to be considered by anyone making a purchase.

pgtaylor wrote, "each SME arm is an individual hand-assembled product and no two samples sound exactly alike."  If true, that is not a virtue.

@dekay 

The effective mass of my SME 3009II (non-improved/detachable head shell) is 12.5 grams.

Yes I was referring to the more common Series II improved - 6.5g effective mass and S2 improved - effective mass 9.5

Maybe the SME 3009 was top tier when it came out fifty or so years ago. If the SME wasn’t top tier back then, which arms were?

I certainly agree with you, when it was released in 1959 it was revolutionary, set a blueprint for arm design to follow, and displayed immaculate construction; however I was reviewing it in the contest of the early 80‘s by which time cartridge and arm design had changed markedly.