Madman! Digital vs Vinyl


Anyone out there who has a great vinyl setup and a great digital setup, try this!

Bring up Elton John’s Tumbleweed Connection Deluxe Edition on Qubuz for digital which includes Madman Across the Water and play it.

 

Then pull out your vinyl of Madman Across the Water and play it.  
 

Please tell me which sounds better on your system and what you have for TT, cartridge and phono preamp.

 

 I won’t bias the results by telling you what I think.

 

 Thanks 

dougthebiker

For as many cd’s or streamed content you show me, I can show you just as many vinyl Lp’s that will sound better. It is in the pressing. Some sound like utter garbage, others will make your head spin played on a good set up. I have yet to hear any digital content that possesses that "tubey magic" that some, not all, Lp’s have.

I find it's highly dependent on the source.  Some streams I listen to have virtually no dynamic range.  They're mastered to be loud, not to sound good.  Others can be stunning.

 

Same with vinyl, everything depends on the pressing, and dead wax info isn't always the complete answer either.  I have a few same matrix pressings that sound a bit different too.

 

I have some really great sounding vinyl of Bill Evans, albeit not the original LPs...likely remastered and I do prefer the vinyl over the CDs I have of the same stuff.

I’ve concluded this.  It all depends on how the source was recorded and you need to spend a lot more on your vinyl rig to exceed digital results.  That said I prefer well recorded vinyl!  My vinyl rig is VPI HW-40, Pass x-27, Van Dre Hul Stradivarius.  Digital is Denafrips Terminator Plus w/ Gaia.