AN Niobium versus Tantalum resistors?


Has anyone compared the two? Non-magnetic versions.

 

I read an interview where AN said something like "The Niobium are amazing when used correctly in conjunction with the tants". Hm.

thanks in advance

clustrocasual

They are .5W because of space issues, I was not able to go higher. I use standard Niobium, which are higher resolution and fuller sounding than Z-Foils, as a comparison. They are the highest resolution resistor I have tried so far and the tone curve feels natural and nothing weird, no rhodium/silver tilt etc. Just a great improvement to the Takman sound I was getting before. You lose a touch of "exciting" metallic felt-texture, but its worth it for the naturalness of the music. And that part is totally subjective anyway.

Have not tried tants but read many reviews of them before deciding. There’s a website which said the Niobiums are "musically" on a higher level than silver tants, although the silver tants may give some improvement in certain areas.

I want to try the silver Niobium this summer. At first I thought I needed them because these began VERY warm and dark, even at 100+ hours. Then they shifted bright and brittle. They went back and forth until you get both warm and top end, but then they are sluggish. Thats when I removed them. But when I put them back, the next 150 hours cleaned and tightened up the sound and they are super solid now. Even bass-heavy techno music sounds as tight as metal resistors, but like a flood gate of music and transparency comes out.

 

your results with full Z-foils mirror my own. Ideally I use a mixture of Z-foils and Takman metals, with a few Caddock MK132 (very full, bold and assertive) and Shinkoh tants (musical and finely textured) thrown in for flavour.

The MK132‘s are very good at balancing the  Z-foils in circuit.

I recommend replace one position of either the Takman or Z-foil with Niobium. I tried a few combos of this.. small differences of these locations, but in all cases the improvement of Niobium was great!

I replaced the VC on my preamp with two AN Silver Tantalum resistors, turning it into a buffer.  The AN silver tants are huge in size and while maybe not exactly neutral they sure are musically enjoyable, IMO.  I have an outboard passive VC with Takman metal film shunt resistors and Vishay z-foil series resistors and it is comparably a little hard (but neutral) sounding compared to my other outboard VC that uses Amtrans AMRG Carbon Film Resistors, which I find to be a good combination of musical and detailed.  I doubt I would gain anything by replacing the AN silver tants with AN Niobium, but it would be easy to do.