The suspension can fail, though. it depends on the rubber, and how it was stored, where it orignated from, how it was handled and applied during manufacturing, etc. multiple aspects to the story, in all cases, so one story of failure or success in age of a cartridge is not comparable to another when it comes to predicting specific outcomes for models or brand sources.
Eg, I have here, 5x of the beryllium cantilevered AM40 Signet cartridges, new in the box. their rubber suspensions went hard and they are a write off, regarding the stylus of each. too bad. They are also, basically, an A-T cartridge, by any measure. and of similar age to an AT440. But these ones failed.
The situation has always been, be very very careful when buying a so called NOS AT cartridge/stylus. This also goes for many others. Buy the given cartridge for the body/motor and if the stylus suspension turns out to not be hardened and useless, then consider yourself very very lucky.
then, watch for wear on your records, very very closely, as distortion may creep into the situation far sooner than one might think. the suspension of that NOS unit may have a very short lifespan.
The main reason one might want such a cartridge is the given beryllium cantilevers and hyper elliptical, or shibata or micro ridge stylus. As getting modern equivalents can be very expensive, and even..completely unavailable.
So don’t buy too much into the hype of old NOS AT cartridges, or any others, including older MC carts, without doing lots of due diligence in research.
No free rides!--a functional working brain, used in continual analysis- is always required, as per the norm in all things. throw money at the new, so you can spend brain power and life/time somewhere else.... or use your noggin/brain..in trying to slip the surly bonds of requisite financial input. for their cantilever suspensions are not immortal, and each case is VERY individual and unpredictable until it is actually tested and run out to the ends of their given life, in the now...
One might get lucky at $50 input..or one second later, you or someone else gets burned at $1200 or more being spent.