@ghasley I simply found important to clarify to @noske, the user that called in AGD (and Atmasphere) implying a possible lack of experience (compared to Purifi) on the matter of technology, specifically on Class D and Silicon. I brought to his attention what the fact are. Is it something that is not allowed in this forum?
Atma-Sphere Class D… Amazing
Today I picked up my Atma-Sphere Class D Amps. These aren’t broken in yet. And they are simply amazing. I’ve listen to a lot of High End Class D. Some that cost many times what Atma-Sphere Class D costs. I wasn’t a fan of any of them. But these amps are amazing. I really expected to hate them. So my expectations were low. The Details are of what I’ve never heard from any other amps. They are extremely neutral. To say the realism is is extremely good is a gross understatement. They are so transparent it’s scary. These amps just grab you and suck you into the music. After I live with them some and get them broken in. And do some comparisons to some other high end Amps Solid State, Tubes and Class D’s, also in other systems I’ll do a more comprehensive review. But for now, these are simply amazing amps.. Congrats to Ralph and his team. You guys nailed on these.
- ...
- 763 posts total
Really? Seems to me as a practical matter, silicon mosfet based class d amps by Hypex and Purifi clearly illustrate performance that not only competes with current GaN amps but in nearly all cases I am familiar with beats them handily in most objective parameters. One can argue that GaN devices offer inherent advantages over silicon mosfets, but unless the implementation exploits those advantages, it is all just a marketing scam. To date I have seen many GaN amp's brought to market, few that actualize these theoretical advantages. |
An informative post with alot going on here. First, I admire that you are tackling a pretty complex DIY active three way speaker system. I also admire that you've been a class d amplifier user for over two decades. Especially so given the evolution of class d amplification during that span.
Now that you have communicated you are in the market for six channels of amplification AND that you can afford to purchase anything you want....I'm still not sure that would change Ralph's mind on supplying you the data you require. It might keep him up at night that you might need troubleshooting assistance with your electronic crossover and getting things to sound right. |
@kuribo Yes, really. As I said it is physics, not a matter of opinion. However you are absolutely right about the implementation issue. GaN Mosfets are much more challenging to use in order to take full advantage of the intrinsic superior performances. Without a deep knowledge of the device physics and experience with the device package mechanical issues, stray inductance, gate drives and overall layout, any improper implementation can demise terribly the electrical and sonic performances. But that it is also true in general since the same argument applies to the implementation of circuits with Tubes, Bipolar devices, Silicon MOSFET, in ClassA, B, C,D, E, F, G, H amplifiers (all topologies of amplifiers). Hope my answer is helping in clarifying a bit more the subject. |
@ghasley |
- 763 posts total