Great analogy @12many
Now add to that crumpled piece of paper a pound of peanut butter sprinkled with sand that was packed into that parcel thoroughly coating every mm of that paper
You will work harder and longer to clean it up to determine that it’s a piece of blank paper 8.5x11. Now your hands are dirty with all the crap you just dealt with to understand what you’re dealing with, you reach into a drawer to pull out a clean piece of paper but you marred it because your hands were dirty. You have a perfect 8.5x11 piece of paper except the remnants of peanut butter and sand. That’s noise that you worked long and hard to clean up but ended up with on a final product.
All digital signal, data packets, etc is nothing but a digital signal being carried thru a copper wire by means of an analog signal that is susceptible to emi, rfi and ground noise. Are you venmoing me a dollar? Will my bank see it as a dollar or $.99.9999 On a receiving end the data packets unfolded properly.
However we’re talking audio and digital to digital and digital to analog conversion that happens inside your audio components. In an ideal world it would have no effect on the final product, all DACs would sound identical and cables wouldn’t matter. Unfortunately in our world it does not work that way and everything matters
I have extensively tested several ethernet cables for several days of critical listening each. I eliminated the possibility for bias as after 1-2 days of listening you begin to hear the true character of the cable (or its effects on a component) without initial impressions getting in a way.
All cables I have tested sounded different. With one causing slight listening fatigue due to a slight hump in the presence region, another sounding hyper detailed which really worked out for me during low level listening, and another just being dead nuts neutral without emphasis on any particular band.
This is my experience in my system that I consider objective as I have spent considerable amount of time critically listening to each option and even reverting back to see if my results match.
The point I’m trying to make is the theories expressed in this and other discussions on this subject are simply what they are - theories and assumptions. Most if not all the contributors who angrily try to convince others that it cannot be because in theory it’s impossible, have never tried or tested it for themselves, don’t have the systems that can reveal these differences, don’t or can’t afford higher end cables or systems or just simply don’t have the ear to hear the changes between the cables.
It’s all good. But there’s no reason, especially without having any experience behind your belt, to tell me what I hear or don’t hear.