1) Failure to understand Klippel measurements
Are you referring to Danny Ritchie claiming this? It took 5 minutes to find engineers taking apart Danny for his lack of knowledge of how Klippel works. If you mean his Magnepan test I cannot comment and neither has Magnepan.
2) Poor testing methodology - eg the tests conducted on the Chord M Scaler
Poor how? The unit does not so anything when connected to a half decent DAC. It's output is very jittery.
3) Failure to read user manuals about tolerances before engaging in testing
Tolerances of what? You are really reaching here.
4) Testing cables for interference when they are not plugged in to anything
Took me a bit longer to understand this, but your comment is false. He tested unconnected to examine shielding and then connected it.
5) Not checking if the samples sent are "cherry picked"
In this topic Amir stated that most of what he tests comes from listeners.
6) A refusal to take responsibility for recommendations when the product quality is not satisfactory eg Topping.
You have both made up a failure rate for topping and no review site does. This is a ludicrous attempt to discredit.
7) Conducting speaker listening tests based on 1 speaker only ( I do not care what he says about the validity of this, as this is nonsense)
It is not that you don't care it is that you are not qualified to make this comment. I read the paper posted. Makes total sense.
8) Reliance on Sinad rather than use industry standard "THD" and "S/N ratio when this an old and arguably inefficient method of measurement.
Flat out incorrect. Have you even read any review on ASR? There are pages of measurements. IMD, SINAD, THD. Many different test levels and frequencies.
9) Listening at ridiculously high volumes eg on the Focal Clear headphones at 115 db. Are you serious??
Another flat out misrepresentation. Did you even read the review?
10) The farcical review of HiFiMan Ananda headphones where he was simply way off beam.
Farcical how? Do you own it and he disagrees?
@laoman I will give you the benefit of the doubt that most of this list is not your own. It was not hard, even at my knowledge level to tear apart your list.
