That is true but not in the manner you are thinking. Gated measurements are used in Klippel for higher frequencies (usually above 1 kHz -- it is a user setting). Lower are generated using field separation giving you very high resolution down to 20 Hz (or even lower) -- something any reasonable sized anechoic chamber can’t do
- The FR was shown through the research to comport with listener preference.
- In a bare 2 channel set up without any DSP (As in pure, or bare, or whatever we want to call it)… then FR is important.
- In a DSP system, FR loses importance.
- Directivity preference varies, but the content of the in and off axis is important to the preference of liking it.
- The actual time domain “polarity” was deemed to be not strongly statistically important. But some people seem to notice it.
- As we know the waterfall shows the FR as well as cabinet ringing.
- Then the distortion seems to be tolerated in low frequencies and in terms of HD, but not very tolerated with FM and IMD.
- Many people do not seem to care about driver distortions and linearity.
I’ll admit I like #3, and I like low distortion drivers (#5).
I cannot imagine a preference for high cabinet ringing and high distortion… but if the O/96 speakers are that, then I can see why people like them.
We may have a problem with the wrong measurements, or with maybe the frequency not extending as low as we would like… but IMO it is more of a problem that most speakers have no measurements. And also all the boutique power cords, IC, and speaker cables have no measurements or specs.
The ones that do have measurements are generally pretty well liked stuff, Mogami, Cardis and other bales and ICs. And Genelec, Dutch-n-Dutch, Bouchard, etc.
However; this thread either started off as an attack on specs, measurements, ASR, or you… it could have been some spreadsheet of what have measurements, and how well the gear is liked to see if there are any correlations… But alas, it is not that.
well… you and I are sticking to the “manufacturers and why they don’t post measurements”.
I am not a shill for any company.
^Agree^, I just did not want it perceived as being a shill.
Companies don't need anechoic chambers. They can simply rent space in one or get Klippel to measure it for them. The cost is less than $2,000 for a speaker. If a company can't afford to do this, or can't be bothered, it is not going to get my support. It is one thing for a DIY to not afford such fees, it is entirely different matter for a major company.
That is true for R&D maybe. But they might need some chamber or way to maintain QA.
Note also that we are not not just looking for a few simple measurements. We want full CEA-2034 plus distortion measurements. A few gated measurements are not going to do it.
Agree.