Open Baffle Experience


Much has been said about open baffles, including an epic website by the late, great Dr. Linkwitz but I've only heard them really once, playing absolutely garbage music (thanks Pure Audio!) at a hotel.

I'm talking here about dynamic drivers in single baffles without enclosures, not ESLs or Magneplanar type systems.

I'm curious who has had them, and who kept them or went back to "conventional" boxes?

I'm not really looking to buy speakers, but I did start thinking about this because of a kit over at Madisound made with high quality drivers.

 

 

erik_squires

If you think open baffles are great, then just remove your drivers from your speakers right now and throw your wooden boxes away folks. You will be shocked how horrible your speakers sound without them. You have been warned. I’m sure Magico and others would not go to all the time and trouble to produce such expensive cabinets if the answer was as simple as having no cabinet at all!

Do not listen to folks who claim open baffles are better than box speakers. They probably cant afford state of the art box speakers which can cost hundreds of thousands of dollars. Its just sour grapes

 

@peter_s - it was the X4 you heard at PAC. That's where I heard them as well. They were pretty impressive, particularly for the price (~8K). 

Don and Jay from Reference North Audio built my Line Force cabinets. They make a lot of the flat packs for GR-Research products (NX-Oticas, NX-tremes, servo subs). The Line Force cabinets are made from composite in order to be strong and stiff enough with all the driver cutouts, so they take longer to make and are considerably more expensive than the MDF flat packs. As far as I know, they are happy to make more of these cabinets.

GR-Research has NEO3 drivers available, but the Bohlender-Graebener NEO10 drivers are no longer available. I purchased my BG Neo10 drivers more than two years ago when they were still sporadically available.

Danny from GR has been trying to make a suitable replacement driver, but so far he hasn't been satisfied with the prototypes. Parts Express has their GRS 10" planar driver available, which can be used with suitable crossover changes, but this driver drops off quickly in the lower frequencies. Danny is working on a crossover using this driver, but I would expect he will have to compromise efficiency to get a flat response. They will probably sound great, but will need more power to drive them. 

This speaker is not inexpensive to build, even though you are only paying for the raw materials. I spent well into five figures for all the drivers, crossover parts, wire and enclosures. And this doesn't include the pair of open-baffle subs that are required since the Line Forces only play down to about 170Hz by themselves.

But they are pretty stunning, even without being broken in. I've heard speakers that rival these, but not many and all well outside of my budget. 

The suggestion to just throw away the box is somewhat simplistic in that the bass and midbass will sound weak. The better sounding open baffle speakers don’t have this issue because the designer selected drivers to compensate and produce a balanced sound. 
 

OB speakers are not inherently better than box speakers… they are different sounding… on some instruments the tone sounds more correct… but as noted the bass pressurizes the room differently. 
 

I’ve heard great box speakers, panel speakers and OBs… and the nice thing about shows like CAF is you can usually hear them all, albeit different rooms and gear. 
 

They are definitely worth a listen. 

@jaytor Thanks for the information. That is really helpful.

To the naysayers, I heard the X4 speakers at the Pacific Northwest audio show, and they were very impressive for their price.  Not out of the park better than any speaker I heard there, but they really stood out for having an organic and natural sound for a lot less money than many of the conventional speakers I heard. I will likely try them out since there is a 60 day audition period, I believe.