I note you have removed the toe-in. This is the purist position. If the production was classic then there was a spaced pair of dipole microphones in front of the musicians. If you don't toe-in you are hearing what the mics heard. If you toe-in, the image of the sound will be spread outwards. A 'hole' may appear in the centre.
Speaker toe-in and listening distance are of course related. Less toe-in is has a similar effect to listening from further away.
I do think you're making a mistake with the wingback. If you like to rest your head perhaps a chair with a smaller headrest to the back of your head not impeding soundwaves' access to the ears.
Or listen with headphones?