I think the slop problem arises because the liquid pivot allows too much movement. Just a few microns will allow the stylus to change location relative to the platter and read signals that are not imparted by the groove. I sometimes wonder whether conventional gimbal bearings are really good enough to give zero slop.
@clearthinker I was thinking the same thing. FWIW Triplanar uses the hardest metal bearings made worldwide to achieve 'zero slop'. To that end to my understanding they have a security clearance to obtain the bearings.