Can the level of pleasure derived from music be measured?


This is a real question that I think may have a answer.

With the right probes in a brain can't changes in the pleasure

zone be measured? 

I ask because it seems to me that without this measurement

a true audiophile hierarchy can not be claimed.

Thoughts??

 

 

128x128jeffseight

A very silly question but I will respond from my usual from my usual standpoint.

Probes could be entered in the brain that measure the concentration of dopamine being secreted.  The more dopamine, the more pleasure.  I'm sure scientists will have done this previously, possibly on animals.

Spend money.  Sounds better.  Pleasurable.

Spend money.  Doesn't sound better.  Not pleasurable.

As it happens, there is a field of psychology called psychometrics that deals specifically with measuring subjective experience. It turns out that brain waves are rather crude for discerning small changes in one's experience. Better are rating scales targeting specific dimensions of perceptual experience. There are four dimensions: a) Valence (good vs bad), b) Potency (strong vs delicate), c) Arousal (relaxing vs stimulating), and d) Novelty (familiar vs. unfamiliar). All of our perceptions are really just a composite of these four factors much like all perceived colors are just a composite of red, green and blue (with a brightness factor thrown in).

I have used psychometrics professionally to measure all manner of perceptual experience including sound quality. Here it is important to note that there is a difference between the physical qualities of sound and the emotional qualities of sound. I always aim to correlate the two to reveal which physical qualities are most predictive of desired perceptions. Not all physical qualities are equally relevant, perceptually. Knowing the differences is what is important.