2. digital
  3. 1249835318

Budget DAC vs new Player

Hello,

I have a Rotel 855CD which has given me excellent service. Recently, I tried a new Emotiva ERC-1 ($400) with mixed results. While the soundstage depth on the Emotiva was superior, the Rotel bested the ERC-1 at the low end and for accurate timbre (a clarinet on the Rotel sounded more like an oboe on the Emotiva!)

So, given that I have limited funds to work with, I was wondering if I should try a DAC, such as the KECES DA-131 Mk II. Or, dollar for dollar value, should I look for another CD Player?

My working assumption is that the limitation on the Rotel is the chipset, not the transport.

Most of my listening is classical music.

Any suggestions or comments you might care to offer will be appreciated.

Rotel 855 CD
NAD T-163 pre/pro
Emotiva UPA 2 amp
Klipsch KG 4

Many thanks,

Jon
opteron05
opteron05 OP
16 posts
 
Johnnyb53

It's been a few years, so I don't remember the brand, but I'm guessing that I spent about $15.00 for it. While I recognize that all cables and connectors can have a significant effect on sound, my limited budget forces me to look for the greatest dollar cost / benefit in my system.

Given my druthers, my system components would be very different and my 11 x 19 room would get acoustic treatment.

I do think that, as the components of the system improve, the effects of changes can be more easily discerned. But, in my situation, I am still sorting out the major components within my limitations. So, for now, at least, I feel that I would realize a more significant effect from a higher quality DAC at $299 (The Music Fidelity V-DAC) than I would from changing to a higher cost cable...

Thanks for your comment.
johnnyb53
3,510 posts
 
08-13-09: Opteron05
...While I recognize that all cables and connectors can have a significant effect on sound, my limited budget forces me to look for the greatest dollar cost / benefit in my system.

...So, for now, at least, I feel that I would realize a more significant effect from a higher quality DAC at $299 (The Music Fidelity V-DAC) than I would from changing to a higher cost cable...
Well, what I am getting at is that since you have a fairly recent DAC in your NAD pre/pro, and are contemplating getting an Emotiva UMC-1, which has an even later generation upconvertling DAC, maybe it's more cost-effective to upgrade the digital link to get the best use of the DACs you have or plan to have, rather than buying yet a third DAC in the V-DAC.

There are some good coax digital cables for significantly less than the V-DAC, such as the Analysis Plus Black for $75/meter, AudioQuest VDM-1 for $65/meter, or Cardas High Speed at $107.

That said, I've heard very good things about the V-DAC, not just from professional reviews, but from a long-distance friend who bought an Oppo DV-980H, a V-DAC, and Cardas High Speed digital cable rather than a $600 CD player. He's VERY happy with his choice.
parasound63
162 posts
 
Any update on what you're doing, Opteron?

-P
More to discover