2. digital
  3. 1298325069

What CDP gets really close to vinyl?

Hello, I have been looking for a CD player that is truly airy, transparent, and in this sense similar to vinyl. So far I did not have much luck. I tried a variety of brands, from Rega to Meridian to Ayre, and now own an EAR Acute. Each of these players is wonderful in its own way, but the sense of spaciousness, air, the "I am there in the symphony hall" feeling has never achieved what I can get with a good turntable and good cart. Has anyone had better luck?
ggavetti
audiofeil
4,011 posts
 
Zmanastronomy,
Thanks for the clarification.

You are indeed correct that very good digital costs far less than very good analog.

Enjoy the NAD.
mrtennis
3,295 posts
 
audiofeil, this is probably the first time i agree with you 100 percent.

the best digital i have ever heard was a 1996 top of the line naim 2 piece cd x cd player and separate power supply. but i would not say that it was better than vinyl, just that it was pleasant, minimally timbrally inaccurate and very listenable. i heard this player at the sahara hotel at ces.
audiofeil
4,011 posts
 
>>03-21-11: Mrtennis
audiofeil, this is probably the first time i agree with you 100 percent<<

This is not good.

Perhaps I need to re-think my position.
muralman1
1,527 posts
 
Audiofeil, you are guessing. I have heard marvelous vinyl systems costing 6 figures. My duo set up brings in the last ounce of detail a recording provides. You would be amazed at how much artistry is available on CDs.
audiofeil
4,011 posts
 
I have very nice digital stuff here when I want to hear material not available on vinyl. Very expensive gear in fact.

But if you want to bring your toys here and have a Muralboy vs. Vinylfeil shootout you'll be embarrassed.

Stomped, crushed, and whipped.

I will serve humble pie of course.

Hot or cold, your choice.
More to discover