2. digital
  3. 1301369843

SACD player

I really hate to start a thread like this but I've been looking for a new SACD player for a couple of weeks now and am getting nowhere. I can't even settle on a brand.

What I'm looking for is the highest quality SACD player I can get for around 2,000.00. I will use it for 2 channel only. I would just like to hear some unbiased opinions before making my final decision.

My current system is Vandersteen Model 3 speakers, McIntosh MC2200 Amp, Marantz SC-11S1 Preamp. Currently using a Pioneer Elite PD-D6-J and it's starting to have some issues. Would like to replace it before it completely craps out.

I have no problem buying used if it's a quality piece.

Thank you in advance for any constructive replies.
m_rycko
mrtennis
3,295 posts
 
hi felitopaz:

how confident are you ?

suppose we compared your modded marantz, with a a modded oppo with tubes. would you bet that i would prefer the marantz ???
paulfolbrecht
603 posts
 
The Sony 5400 spanks the Marantz players. Yes, the Marantz players are 'warmer', but that does NOT mean they are easier to listen to or more like vinyl. IMO, they are not. They just have midbass hump and slightly rolled top end. (They are great on good material, but still not as good as the Sony on good material.)

The ModWright Sony 5400 comes within spitting distance of good material on good material.

But there is still so much more good material on vinyl (Ok, I'm talking about jazz) that vinyl still walks all over what digital gives you overall.
paulfolbrecht
603 posts
 
I meant to say "The ModWright Sony 5400 comes within spitting distance of good VINYL on good material."
missioncoonery
1,221 posts
 
This is exactly where I was a year ago.I listened to several including the Sony 5400,Marantz11S2 and the Oppo which are being suggested above.The Sony did nothing for me,the Marantz a little better but what I decided and did was saved more cash and bought an Esoteric.Blows all these away.Yea it cost me more cash,something like 1200 bucks but well worth the time waiting and cash spent.2 grand will buy a SA10/demo or slightly used one this site,actually a little less and that will outperform those listed above..just my opinion..Good luck
mrtennis
3,295 posts
 
hi pualfobrecht:

before i purchased the oppo 83se modded unit from modwright, i asked about the sony.

he told me he took both to the 2010 rocky mountain show and the sentiment was almost evenly divided between the two units.

he thought i would prefer the oppo because he considered it more tube like, to s slight degreee than the modded sony.

you can ask him about both units.

i ended up with the modded oppo with the 2 6sn7 tubes and rectifier tube.

i'm confident that the sony is also an excellent player, as well.
More to discover