2. digital
  3. 1327170664

Ripping SACD vs regular CD

I have been ripping my CD's using DB Poweramp and have gotten to my SACD's. Some are duplicate titles that I have already ripped a CD for. Is there any advantage to utilizing the SACD cd layer rip? I dont want to overwrite the MOFI DSOTM with the SACD cd layer if its not superior. I could put them in a seperate folder if there is an advantage.
stl114_nj
mrtennis
3,295 posts
 
i have two versions of a cd. the first is the original. then it was remastered as a hybrid sacd. i compared the hybrid layer with the redbook layer of the original cd and preferred the hybrid layer.

so, it would seem intuitive that copying the hybrid layer may give an aadvantage over copying the first version.
swampwalker's avatar
swampwalker
5,138 posts
 
My strong supposition is that ripping the SACD layer will be of no use unless you have a DSD capable DAC, of which there are very few, IIRC.
hfchoi
6 posts
 
There's nothing that can rip the sacd layer. There's not even any non-proprietary sacd digital out. It's to stop people ripping it.
brubacca
5 posts
 
Depending on your drive you can rip the cd layer of a hybrid sacd. I have ripped that exact disc. I have one drive that works and one that doesn't.

In a case where your cd is old and the sacd is remastered it would be better to rip the remastered version.
ozzy's avatar
ozzy
7,486 posts
 
I use the SACD layer analog outputs to a stand alone Tascam CDR.
The Analog outputs from my Cary player playing the SACD layer is of higher quality than the CD layer.

The CDR recording won't be at 24 bit but it usually sounds much better than staright digital.
More to discover