Steve, thanks very much for your comments and insights.
My one comment in response is in regard to:
Also, as indicated in your paper:
Regards,
-- Al
My one comment in response is in regard to:
10-06-12: AudioengrThe problem as I see it, in at least most cases, is that there is no practical way for the consumer to know what the transport's output impedance or the DAC's input impedance is. Even JA's measurements don't address those parameters, at least in the reviews I've looked at. And, if I recall correctly, the tolerance defined by the S/PDIF standard is a very loose one, something like +/- 20 ohms or +/- 20%.
"Characteristic impedance different than 75 ohm can be very good, as Al mentioned, if it is better match for given system."
Sure, but I would sell that system and get one that meets the specs so I dont have to try to find a wacked-out cable that matches it.
Also, as indicated in your paper:
I have never seen impedance control on any Transport or DAC circuit board. Occasionally, the wiring from the circuit board to the connector is impedance-controlled, but this is the exception, not the rule.It all seems to me to add up to a very hit or miss situation, and even more so given that another key parameter, the risetime and falltime of the transport's output signal, is also usually unspecified, and widely variable (e.g., 25 ns or so in many cases, per your paper; 3 ns or less in some cases, per your statement above).
10-06-12: DuraSee Steve's paper, linked to above, which explains it all nicely.
... and then there is impedance match which I frankly do not quite understand.
Regards,
-- Al