Do you think you need a subwoofer?


Why almost any one needs subwoofers in their audio systems?

I talk with my audio friends about and each one give me different answers, from: I don't need it, to : I love that.

Some of you use subwoofers and many do in the speakers forum and everywhere.

The question is: why we need subwoofers ? or don't?

My experience tell me that this subwoofers subject is a critical point in the music/sound reproduction in home audio systems.

What do you think?
Ag insider logo xs@2xrauliruegas
Dear Pryso: The big Evolution Acoustic speakers are a good example of a full range design that does not needs external powered sub's because things are that the Evolution speaker design already have it and integrated to the speaker.

This Evolution speaker design is a good example where the designers take in count the critical importance of the low bass subject and the need that that bass range will be handled by a dedicated woofer/amplifier ( like the sub's. )

I can't say for sure the croosover frequency Evolution's woofers that handle the " sub " bass but maybe lower than 80Hz or maybe the owner can choose it.

Perhaps M. Levigne could share this info with us and can give us his thoughts/experiences on the sub's/low bass whole subject, could you Mike?, thank you in advance.

Regards and enjoy the music.
Raul.
For me as our living room is really big(11X12)I was hesitant in trying 2 subs.to some folks I might do things backwards.
in four years we bought a 900sq.ft. house,and of course I love audio.So I have been buying gear suited more for a bigger room.My speakers are revel 50as,Bryston 28B-sst+7B-sst+1X4Bsst,2XDD-15 subs.One which I have been using just for the .1 for movies.Raul suggested trying the 2 in stereo.
As I don't have much room I tried it in front of my speakers.One sub was good if you were sitting where I was sitting.Using two in stereo solidified the bottomend(Way more) and gave me way more soundstage depth,almost a 3-D effect.I imagine some are thinking,two DD-15s in a 11X12 room.And why i am I not using satellite for mains.the revels put out a nice bottom end(stereo direct)But adding a sub makes it way more solid,like a we'll recorded kick drum or bass guitar.adding two just makes it very enjoyable(more like a live event).I have no boominess,bloat,no nasties.I could only imagine when we add on to our house or buy a bigger house,how much more I'll get out of her.I thought two subs
might be too much(quite the opposite if you listen and be patient when adjusting the subs).I do Y cables out of my R+Lpre to amps and subs,speakers set to large.I have the subs X-over at 64 hz,as my speakers supposedly go down to 32-34 hz.I will try the X-over at 80hz and see.I like where their at now,very emotionally musically satisfied,BUT.Anyway it was a great surprize integrating the other sub,only one problem,I need another sub for my movies now,Thanks Raul.
Dear Drummermitchel: Nice to see that your sub's stereo integration was/is sucessful, congratulations.

Like you say we have to " listen and be patient " to achieve good results.
You even still have " land " to make a little change try it and listen for an improvement or not: to use the high-pass on your DD ones to liberate ( lowering the IMD on the main speakers ) your Revel's from low bass. You can do it and see what happen.

Regards and enjoy the music.
Raul.
Drummermitchel, did you mean to say "our living room is NOT really big(11X12)"?

Your post is a bit confusing. You reference buying a 900 sq. ft. home, then you say "So I have been buying gear suited more for a bigger room."

Now if you are happy with your sound, that is what really matters. It is just surprising to me that if your room is really 11' x 12' and you installed a pair of Revels and two DD-15 that you have room for the system to breath and image and you are not blown out by the bass. But maybe that was your point?
Dear Pryso: Yes, I agree with you: not really big.

This is the real " magic " of sub's alternative: it does not matters ( almost ) on the room because we are talking in the subs alternative mainly about low bass quality more than quantity.

In my experience two sub's always perform better than one in a room, two sub's makes the response be smoother.

Jloveys and Halcro point out that the ideal number is four sub's and there is the link to a scientific studies about made by Harman International elsewhere in this thread. Anyway the best way to go is when you listen it in your own system: you can't believe what you are hearing and the huge improvement in the quality system performance.

Btw, Dgob ( He posted in this thread ) has a very small room and he integrate two sub's in true stereo fashion with very good results too.

Regards and enjoy the music.
Raul.