Dynavector Karat 17D2 vs Sumiko Blackbird

Which phono stage are you using? You need to consider the low output of the Karat. I'm using a Lehmann Cube SE and the Karats 0.23mV is probably near the limits of that phono stage testing its noise floor (which is really good) and gain stages. The Blackbird is 2.5mV I think which really opens up your options.

The Dyna is easy to set up. I had to get a different counter weight, but that's no problem. VPI carries it.

They are both good cartridges, so either way you'll be happy, but after my Dyna wears out, I'll buy another one. There's nothing at the price range I'd rather have that I've heard anyway.

I'm using a Rogue Audio SS phono stage.