2. analog
  3. 1173141648

Cartridge comparison for best match

I have a VPI TNT IV but with Aires feet. I am using an Eminent Technolgy 2.5 tone arm with the high pressure manifold. The table sits on a Vibraplane table which in turn sits on the VPI stand. I have enjoyed a VdH Black Beauty Cartridge for over 10 years. I am using 2 Krell KPAs in balance mode as my phono preamp. I am looking to upgrade my cartridge but have not followed the technology so am trying to get up to speed. I have read about the Airtight PC1, Black Diamond, Benz Micro Ebony LP, Dynavector XV-1s, Lyra Skala, Clearaudio Goldfinger, VdH Colibri, and VdH Condor. Comparisons and advice welcomed.
128x128krc
krc's avatar
krc OP
16 posts
 
I incorrectly identified one of the cartridges in the start of this thread as the Black Diamond. It should have been the Magic Diamond. Any input on this cartridge would be appreciated. I seemed to be leaning towards the Airtight PC1 or the Magic diamond. Any opinions on this comparison? Thanks.
jaybo
4,478 posts
 
i still believe a retip is the ticket...even if you get another cartridge, that van den hul was by all accounts...lightning in a bottle...still a benchmark, and an extremely rare piece as well..good luck
ctm_cra
86 posts
 
Krc - If you have to have a MC, you may want to consider the following in addition to some of the above recommendations:

Miyabi/47 Labs
Dynavector XV-1S

Both made easy the decision to sell my KRSP, Condor and Shelter 901 when AB'd on my VPI extended Aries with multiple 12.5/12.6 arm wands.

I would include the Colibri, however ordering one requires that you are very specific about the sonic strengths and weaknesses of your system. The Colibri is not for everyone. When setup in the right system, however, it is simply untouchable and the musical experience is unforgettable.

Now because of the different options like coil type, cantilever length, body material, etc. it will require that you first dialog with a dealer before one is ordered. Even if you were to listen to a demo unit, the sound you hear may need to be qualified depending on what type of Colibri is used. It's been said that if you come a cross a Colibri for sale and you like it, buy it! Ordering one may not yield the same sonic results as the one that impressed you.

Best regards!
krc's avatar
krc OP
16 posts
 
Jaybo .. i have sent the BB off to get rebuilt. I still believe that the current set of new cartridges will surpass its' otherwise very excellent performance ... which I have enjoyed for 10+ years. Ctm cra, thank you for adding to this thread. The Dyanvector and Miyabi have both received good press. I have heard some feel that the Colibri is somewhat lean ... which is why he developed the Condor.
More to discover