Vintage Technics SL-1000A vs Pro-Ject Debut or Exp


I'm the original owner of a stock Technics SL-1100A, currently with a 25 yr old Shure V15 V-MR cartridge. I'm just dragging it back out after years of storage to revisit my LP collection. It seems to work fine and is in good repair.

I'd be interested in making some reasonable upgrades to this turntable, and would like your thoughts on those, but I'd also like to get a better idea of how good this table really is or can be in comparison/rank with current tables like the Pro-Ject Debut/Expression lines and similarly priced new tables.

Has table technology advanced to the point where I'd be better off buying new, or would I be better off doing some upgrades to the old Technics?

http://i268.photobucket.com/albums/jj13/zacamomusic/HiFi/SL1100A.jpg

Thanks
Geo815

Technics SL-1100A
Cambridge Azur 640P
Cary SLI-80 F1 Integrated
Njoe Tjoeb 4000 CD Player
Triangle Celius ES Speakers
geo815
In my experience, it will benefit from damping under the tonearm-mounting plate (a zinc die-casting?), but I base that on using a Grace 707 arm on the SL-110's undrilled plate-- pretty thin, and having only a few ribs. I don't know if your particular armboard is thicker/better/damped underneath.

Technics did offer an optional wood board (mahogany it looks like in their photos), which I have only seen on eBay a couple of times. Perhaps having a wood plate made to replace your metal plate would be a nice thing, using whatever wood seems best to those who know (I don't). I remember mine did not look too hard to replicate in hardwood or birch plywood, acrylic, or even an acrylic/aluminum/acrylic sandwich.

I have always enjoyed the sonic improvements that the original "Platter Matter"-brand turntable mat has made on my various turntables. It comes up every 3-6 months on eBay and Audiogon. Mine is dark green/turquoise, which I think was the only color (when I was a retailer). One must wash it with dishsoap in the sink once in awhile, so it then sticks (literally) to the platter and to the LP.

I do know your stock Technics rubber mat is at least above average - not too hard, not too soft. A Michell record clamp would help your present setup, for not much $$.

Switch to a magnesium headshell with better wires sometime, and remove the rubber washer on its end. Hopefully such a shell will come with an adjustment for your azimuth. I think the one from Nagaoka does.

Is there any way to adjust VTA on your tonearm?

Contact someone about making an "Arc" protractor for cartridge-alignment in your stock tonearm. Makes a big difference over the best two-point alignments I have performed.

Some have said to unplug the strobe-light module when not in use-- I haven't bothered.

Have fun!

Best regards,
Roy Johnson
Designer
Green Mountain Audio
By the way, with the changes I mentioned above, you may not care if a Project is somehow 'better', as this particular Technics has a good, solid bearing for proper dynamic response, and it does have nice pace, rhythm and clarity. One reference for me on this is our Micro Seiki BL-91 heavy belt-drive TT. And I still enjoy the Technics.

Perhaps the ultimate limitation of your TT will be its stock tonearm, but as I never got a chance to use it, I am only speculating. However, I can tell you that a few years after your TT was introduced, large improvements in tonearm design appeared from Audiocraft, Fidelity Research, Grace, Micro Seiki, Mistubishi (on their DP-EC20 TT), Technics, and others.

Best regards,
Roy
Roy-
Thanks so much for the response and your insights. All very good ideas. I'm going to jump into the damping project this weekend.

I'd like to get a custom arc protractor made to see if I can optimize the stock arm - can you recommend any vendors for that?

Also would be interested in upgrading the arm, but don't know where to start for sourcing an arm board. I would think the exactness of the cutout and mounting holes would make or break it. Any ideas on sourcing?

I did contact KAB, and although they're very familiar with other Technics models, he wasn't able to offer much in the way of specific upgrades help on the SL-1100.

George