Why mono?

So, would any of the posters who own mono carts care to list which manufacturers in their experience offer 'true' mono carts as opposed to repurposed stereo ones, with distinct generators and suspensions that aren't for use with stereo records, and maybe what they think of those ones they've heard?

The thought occured to me -- since it stands to reason that stereo CD players can't suffer from whatever ill effect it's supposed to be that's said to make stereo carts less than optimal for playing mono LPs -- that if this alleged deficiency in playng mono LPs with stereo carts is true, then on average, mono CDs therefore ought to sound better relative to the their mono LP counterparts than do stereo CDs relative to stereo LPs (for those of us using stereo carts -- most, I'm sure).

This isn't something I've noticed however, not that I've specifically listened for it. (Then again, despite owning more vinyl than "discs" by a factor of over 20 to 1, neither am I one who thinks LP sound is necessarily always better than CD sound. I think mastering quality greatly trumps format, but also that, mastering quality aside, each format can have its strengths relative to the other.)

I have a Koetsu Urushi & Lyra Helikon mono Cartridges.
The Koetsu sounds very good on mono records but the Lyra is so much better on them. The image seems to be better layered and taller. I have a few mono records that also sound like crap with lots of surface noise whan played with the stereo cartridge but sound like there is nothing wrong with them when played with the mono cartridge. When I am shopping for mono albums I only look for in groove defects and damace and do not even worry about scratch that would make me not buy the album if it were a stereo recording.
Monos just sound best with a mono album. IMHO

In answer to an earlier question on whether I've tried summing the signal after the fact, the answer is yes, but too long ago to say anything meaningful about it.

It's worth revisiting, and I intend do so, but at the moment, it's all I can do to iron out the wrinkles in order to get the Stelvio II flying in formation in time for RMAF.

Cheers,
Thom @ Galiber

Agree with Mikelavigne. The Miyajima Mono BE-low plays wonderful in a heavy arm like the FR-66s - The Beatles Monos, never heard them like this before.