Your expectation might be skewed I feel...my sim i5.3 is on the fritz and they don't seem to be in any hurry to help me get fixed...Sorry I don't have any experience to your specific players,but I did replace it with the 105d...
I have had that (sim) player for 7 years and really got comfortable with the house sim sound...as you are w/what ever your player was...
I believe you shouldn't expect it to sound like anything other than an oppo 105d...saying that...it is not as over emphasized on any of the frequency extreems/...neutral fits this player.
There are so many pluses to this player over my sim (detail,strings,ect)...it cant be justified...It does sound decent in my system and that's all that matters...and is upgradable as you are surely aware...A lot of retailers offer 30-60 return?...I hope this helps.