Sorry for updating this a month later, haha. I've been pretty busy and forgot I ever made this thread. Today I decided to play a record on my turntable after resetting the tracking force and anti-skate, and the problem's still there. Then I remembered that when I first got the turntable, the belt slipped loose, so I ended up stretching it a lot (because I didn't know what to do with it/where to slip it on) before finally figuring out what it was supposed to do. I don't have a strobe light at home, and am too lazy to make one out of a flashlight, so I'm going to go ahead and buy a replacement belt from LP Gear, and see if that solves the problem.
Thanks again, haha.
Thanks again, haha.