Lyra Kleos or EMT TSD 15 for Rega P9

Ktn, the TSD15 has a colourful big bold sound, superbly macro dynamic and full sound without sacrificing anything in the high frequency. You get a impactful, forceful sound which is more like analogue. The Lyra is more like a modern day sound, precisely cut, less meat more bones, somewhat tipped towards highs, faster, somewhat cleaner, slightly higher in resolution altogether a bit like CDs.

Pani,

Your observations are invaluable...thank you so much. I just wanted to add one more cart to the discourse: any opinions on the Benz Micro Ruby TR? I have a suitable step-up, an A23 Hommage T1. If I go for the tsd 15, would have to trade for a suitable tranny. Thanks again.

What a coincidence Ktn, I am myself looking to upgrade to a Ebony TR (it is not Ruby TR I suppose). Since you have the SUT for it, I think it is a better bet compared to both TSD15 and Lyra. The TR supposedly (I have not heard it personally) has the midrange of TSD15 and speed of Lyra. I am hoping to upgrade to it, but I dont have the step up for it.

Pani,

I have the opportunity to trade in the A23 Hommage T1 for a T2 which is similar but designed for the output and impedance characteristics of the EMT TSD 15. Do you think such a combo is comparable to a Benz Ebony TR/T1 tranny. In other words, does the EMT TSD 15 come close to the Benz Ebony TR given both are wired to suitable trannies? From what I have gathered, the Benz is described as more refined and nuanced but less macrodynamic than the TSD 15. Any thoughts?

Ktn- Just wanted to echo what Pani said about the Tsd-15 sound. I think he is right on with his description. I am not sure about the Ebony TR working with the Homage T1, but I would think that to be a great match. As you likely know, a popular online mag reviews the TR w/ the T1. I am going to throw one more fish in the pond, the DV XX2. I have not heard it, but l recently spent some time with the 20 X2. My Tsd-15 isn't going anywhere, but I was very impressed with the 20 X2. It also was mounted on a Rega arm, and is a very nice match. Perhaps the DV sound may tow the line between the Delos/Tsd-15. I believe the DV's also match well with the Homage.