Nice thread Detlof. I wish we would talk about music more.
Garfish and Detlof agreed. Imperfect as reproduction is: if your "drawn into" it as Detlof says, or if the reproduction makes you want to "get up and dance", as Garfish says, well, I think you have succeeded. It doesn't much matter what we call it or how we label it at that point.
"Talking about jazz is like dancing about potatoes"
Who said that?
I am having a brain cramp. But isn't it true in a way? Charles Mingus? or was it Potter Stewart?
Sincerely, I remain
Garfish and Detlof agreed. Imperfect as reproduction is: if your "drawn into" it as Detlof says, or if the reproduction makes you want to "get up and dance", as Garfish says, well, I think you have succeeded. It doesn't much matter what we call it or how we label it at that point.
"Talking about jazz is like dancing about potatoes"
Who said that?
I am having a brain cramp. But isn't it true in a way? Charles Mingus? or was it Potter Stewart?
Sincerely, I remain