Upgrading cartridge used or new?

Well, I've bought three used cartridges, and I've had nothing but good luck.
All three were in great shape. (Admittedly one was from a friend, so that one might not count.)

My recommendation is to research who you're buying from, (check their feedback and if the post regularly), and speak to them on the phone.

Good luck!

I have had no problem buying used. My best experience, a low hours Koetsu Roseawwod Signature for $950, on the gon. I used it for 3 trouble free years and sold it as used, for only a little less than I paid for it. Clearly there are risks, but that is reflected in the low price for second hand cartridges.

No way! Would you buy used tires for your car? Why take a chance and ruin your vinyl with someones old clunker?

So far the mixed opinions continue along the discussion, I am thankful that all of you are taking your precious time to write about your experience shopping for cartridges, such a delicate important part in our hobby.
Thanks

Hi, Mountainsong; the replies you get aren't necessarily going to reflect the overall opinions on buying new or used. It's a limited sample of people that are willing to take the time to reply. But you probably already knew that.

The question you should ask yourself is: Am I willing to take a chance on buying used in order to get a cartridge that I couldn't afford otherwise? And, if the used cartridge shows up damaged, am I willing to then have to spend even more money to either repair it or buy another cartridge? (Some sellers will allow you to return the cartridge, but then they’re at risk because you might have damaged the cartridge.)

It’s a gamble, and you have to be willing to accept the outcome if you lose. I tried buying used cartridges twice and both times they were damaged. I was able to return one and got stuck with the other. So I didn’t save any money and actually spent more money than if I’d just purchased a new cartridge in the first place. I won’t ever buy a used cartridge again unless I know and trust the seller. And I want a money-back guarantee that the cartridge is in the stated condition.

Good luck if you buy used. :-)

Regards,
Tom