SOTA I-clamp vs Reflex clamp


I am trying to decide between these two. The price difference is steep enough to raise the question is one "better" than the other? I've seen a lot of reviews on the Reflex but very little on the I-clamp. Especially comparing them. Does anybody have experience with the I-clamp?
mhighley96
I have both, and use the Reflex exclusively on my Sapphire. I tried the I-Clamp on my PL-15D, and it just didn't work all that well on that, either. Went with an old Audiocraft SD-600 clamping weight for the Pioneer - much more satisfactory. In general, mass is your friend.

Good luck & happy listening!
Mhighley96...I don't think your Thorens has quite enough mass for a reflex clamp. That clamp really needs a massive, heavy table to work properly.

I would recommend a weight instead. The Aluminati is fantastic and would work very well with your TD150. I have one one my Rega P25 and Matt threaded another for me, that I use on one of my VPI tables. These are truly excellent!
You might want to consider the Michell reflex clamp. It's light weight and you have the option of using it in reflex mode. It's supplied with a felt washer that you place on the spindle under the record. You clamp down with enough force to help flatten the record.

I have both Michell and Sota reflex clamps, but I rarely use them in reflex mode. Either will work to hold the record in place. The Michell is a bit shallower so extra tall spindles could be a problem. I doubt if that applies to Thorens, but I'm not sure.
http://www.michell-engineering.co.uk/accessories/record-clamp/