Rwwear, skepticism is allowed.
Does a conductor's judgment become convoluted by hearing dozens of symphonies?
Does a circuit designer's judgment become convoluted by designing dozens of circuits?
Your argument that the more experience I have makes me less of a good judge of a phenomenon is weak.
I used to be every bit as skeptical, until I got over it (i.e. put my pride aside and actually compared).
BTW, I don't disagree that humans are horrible at double blind listening tests. However, I also insist that humans have phenomenal capacity to hear distinctions in sound/music. The rub is that I believe we have poor acoustic memory, which makes us poor at the testing. So, both are true; there are differences in sound which are easily heard, but we are poor at matching/identifying precisely sound snippets under tightly controlled conditions.
Based on studies about recall and the human mind (i.e. how poor people are at describing/recalling details to police what they saw as an eyewitness) I think I have pretty good ground to stand on for my position. :)
Does a conductor's judgment become convoluted by hearing dozens of symphonies?
Does a circuit designer's judgment become convoluted by designing dozens of circuits?
Your argument that the more experience I have makes me less of a good judge of a phenomenon is weak.
I used to be every bit as skeptical, until I got over it (i.e. put my pride aside and actually compared).
BTW, I don't disagree that humans are horrible at double blind listening tests. However, I also insist that humans have phenomenal capacity to hear distinctions in sound/music. The rub is that I believe we have poor acoustic memory, which makes us poor at the testing. So, both are true; there are differences in sound which are easily heard, but we are poor at matching/identifying precisely sound snippets under tightly controlled conditions.
Based on studies about recall and the human mind (i.e. how poor people are at describing/recalling details to police what they saw as an eyewitness) I think I have pretty good ground to stand on for my position. :)