2. pc-audio
  3. 1352421146

Rip CD to Mac - basic question

I have started to rip some of my CDs to disk using a mac. I notice a lot of people using software to do this. When I look at a CD in the finder it appears as a set of aiff files for each song, for which I have been doing a drag and drop onto my hard drive, just like copying any other file. I would rather not use iTunes.

My question is: is this a bit for bit perfect copy? If so, why use other software? If not, why not? Computer files are always bit perfect when copied. There must be some software intervention on the part of the OS anyway, as a CD doesn't contain aiff files.

Any help would be appreciated. I don't want to copy a lot of CDs like this and then find I have to do it call over again.
malcolm02
audioengr
3,282 posts
 
iTunes ripping is not optimum and makes many mistakes, including no Accurate-Rip check, no C2 error correction and offset errors. These all impact SQ.

The best way to rip to AIFF or ALAC on the Mac is using XLD. Here are some other tips as well as the XLD free download link:

http://www.empiricalaudio.com/computer-audio/

do a comparison of an iTunes ripped file and the same XLD ripped file.

Steve N.
Empirical Audio
rlwainwright
1,904 posts
 
I may have posted incorect info., sorry. I did not know that AIFF was lossless. I *still* would not box myself in with Apple-specific solutions...

-RW-
malcolm02 OP
43 posts
 
Audioengr: "do a comparison of an iTunes ripped file and the same XLD ripped file."

Right, it should be possible to do a comparison of files. I'd be interested to see the results if someone has done it. Maybe I will do it myself if I can figure out how.
malcolm02 OP
43 posts
 
Rlwainwright: "I may have posted incorect info., sorry. I did not know that AIFF was lossless. I *still* would not box myself in with Apple-specific solutions..."

I knew aiff is lossless - I didn't realize it's Apple specific. We live and learn. Thanks.
audioengr
3,282 posts
 
"Right, it should be possible to do a comparison of files. I'd be interested to see the results if someone has done it. Maybe I will do it myself if I can figure out how."

I am talking about listening comparisons. That's what matters isn't it?

If you are trying to find a technical explanation, good luck. Even a score of experts have not succeeded in that.

Steve N.
Empirical Audio
More to discover