Speakers recommendations when placement is an issue


I could use some help with speaker recommendations-I am restricted to placement with speakers flanking a 6 foot built-in entertainment center and 1-2 feet from the back wall. Currently using Linn LP-12, PSE electronics, CAL Icon MK II. Want to start the upgrading process with floor-standing speakers, however, because of limited placement I don't want to waste money on Avalons or ProAc if I can't make them sing! Any speakers that can provide good sound in this setup? Budget is fairly open. thanks!
128x128oaklore
You poor bugger! That is a pretty restrictive picture you are painting in-so-far as getting decent performance out of some speakers goes. It strikes me that a wide dispersion speaker design like the aforementioned ProAcs and Avalons would be a very bad idea. All speakers of that nature project full-range sound almost omni-directionally and need lots of unrestricted breathing space around them to work well.

What you should be looking at are speakers that have a limited dispersion characteristic and an over-damped bass that won't get boomy with near wall placement. Of conventional speakers, the only ones that come to mind are Dunlavys and Duntechs. The original designer of both and current designer/principle of Dunlavy insets his tweeter and mids into the cabinet with a surround of dense foam to both time-align and control the directivity of these drivers. He also favors the overdamped bass you will need, designing sealed cabinet woofer alignments in big boxes. I would look at the Dunlavy 3 and 4. My experience with the 4s in a near-rear wall set-up was very positive. However, it would be good if the sidewalls were at least 3-4 feet away.

A more radical approach to controled dispersion would be to consider horn speakers. The throat of the horn serves to focus the speakers output over a very defined area and thus avoid reflections off of nearby objects that would otherwise color the sound. Good Luck!
I agree with what Vince is saying. You are getting yourself into a situation where you have to ask yourself what you can live with and what you can live without. You will be able to get by without a good soundstage and imaging if the sound is smooth from top to bottom. To get smooth bass from a floor standing speaker next to the wall nearly requires that you have adjustable bass output. I think you would be happier along the upgrade path with getting a good LCR setup and using a subwoofer to dial-in the bass. I think the Thiel MCS1 would do the trick. I use it as my center channel and am impressed with it. SGHT also really liked them. They are musical, work well with different placements, have good directionality, and won't give you bass problems. Just a thought.

Good luck!

Gregg
The Piega's make some speakers that are specifically designed for placement close to the back wall. They are beautiful sounding and a true value speaker.

What is your budget?
I have a similar problem, 1 speaker in a corner next to AV rack , speakers 1.5 feet from back wall. My Bohlender Graebener 501's have a good soundstage and wide sweet spot, They do need about 200 hours break in, a large amp and a subwoofer. After the break in, bi-amped to a madrigal 7.1 amp, they do sing.