Larger Apogee's: Do they beam ?


I was curious if current or past owners of the larger Apogee's would consider this to be a small or wide sweet-spot type of speaker. This is not meant to be a trick question, i'm simply trying to research various "panel" type speaker designs, driver lay-out and dispersion patterns. I would also appreciate comments on ANY planar / ribbon / e-stat design that you think offers a relatively wide sweet spot. If you have ideas as to why this design achieves what it does, i'd love to hear those thoughts too : ) Sean
>
sean
I will only be able to provide a listener's perspecive no clue on the "how" side. I found that Apogees (particularly Divas) had what I would consider a pretty generous sweet spot from side to side, though the soundstage changed considerably as listening height changed, necessitating careful adjustments (in my room, with my setup).

Compared to a number of dynamic speakers with great imaging (Avalon and Kharma are two manufacturer's whose speakers I have owned more recently), the sweet spot on the Apogee Diva was huge! (at least in the range of positions from which you could appreciate the near-full width and depth of the soundstage)

Hope that helps at all...

Jacob
I've owned Apogees and MartinLogans and have heard many models from both manufacturers that I did not own. Two generalities I've drawn are: 1) Horizontally, ML has a narrower sweet spot, and 2) Vertically, the Apogee has less dispersion. The vertical dispersion on Apogees appears limited to height of the ribbon and has a "wet blanket" effect on the highs when your ears exceed the ribbon height. This shouldn't be a problem on any Apogee all-planar models with the exception of the Caliper and Stage which are each shorter than a standing person's ears. Because you asked about the "sweet spot", I guess the vertical aspect is not really on point, here. But, it was the only major limitation in the dispersion arena for the Apogees I've heard.

The ML's narrow sweet spot has not been an issue for me because usually when I listen critically, I listen alone. The sweet spot is wide enough for one person--but not much more! btw--I'm not commenting on the quality of the reproduction in this comparison, just the "sweet spot" size.

So, since you asked about planars with a wide sweet spot, I'd say the Apogees certainly better the MLs.