3 Way Speakers


Is there an advantage of buying a 3 Way Speaker when Compared with a 2 Way Speaker.
rkolluri
Short answer: 1)Frequency response and 2) dynamic response/tone. With technology the way it is it is near impossible to cover the range of frequencies needed for music which are often quoated as 20Hz to 20kHz, or get even very close with a two way speaker. In addition, a two way speaker tends to(not always)push the drivers to their limit in order to cover as much as possible. The result is poorer sound. You will have a tweeter no matter what. In a two way system you are stuck asking the remaining driver to give you nice deep base and clear tight mids. The cone tends to be over worked and breaks up because you are asking it to do so many things (read distortion). Some systems ask the tweeter to do too much too. Tweeters hate that...to much excursion. If the crossover's rolloff rate(this controls how your tweeter shuts down as it receives lower frequencies) isn't steep enough your little tweet will crap out on you. On the other hand if you do not ask your tweeter to go to lower Hz than the burden falls on the poor remaing driver to fight a two front war so to speak.

Most 2 way systems are therefore designed as a comprimise. The middle frequencies (really most essential for listening) are muddied because either the tweeter or remaining driver is trying to handle too much, or the base is sacrificed in order to keep the mid-range better. A 2 and 1/2 way and 3 way system redistributes the load - more hands make lighter work.

That being said, there are some great 2 way systems out there and I have a very nice one myself in my office. They are nice because you can make them so small and in small rooms they fit the bill. (more driver surface, 3 speakers, will move more air and make more sound, sometimes you do not need that either)

IMHO, It is not how many drivers you have but the design and the quality of crossover that is important. I would much rather have a well designed 2 way, with good innerds (great design in the frequency distribution, and quality coils and caps) than a run of the mill 3 way. It is amazing how poor the quality of some crossovers is.

I'd say more but geez... I have to go to work.

Sincerely, I remain
usually given the same price point the 2 way will be the better sounding unit. Some three ways like the vandersteen 2 will compete out of it's price class. Usually the two way has an advantage of a less complex cross over and a better budget to spend on 2 drivers instead of three. The advantage of the three way if you get everything right is less complex signals for each driver to handle as well as often the ability to get better bass, since you don't have to use as small mid/bass driver. Thake each design on it's own merrits though. there are no hard and fast rules here.
The Pipe Dream is really a two way. just a diferent approach that can work very well. multiple small woofers can move alot of air and are low mass, say 16 or more 1" dome tweeters can also move air like a larger driver but with reduced mass. Listen to the sound coming out of the thing and let that be your guide.
If the speaker drivers were full range, than It wouldn't make a sence to even buy a 2Way speaker. There is no speaker driver that can produce a full range. Planar speakers still need a sub for a bottom end.
Theoretically 3Way design tended to get closer to the full range than 2Way design.
I prefere quality 2Way designs over 3Way(faster, more transparent, easier to drive, less signal path, more natural)