"However I am a little skeptical that I can solve this with just and amp. All ears open for a relative newbie."
You did make some mistakes (as we all do) but the above quote is a good call on your part. Don't waste your money on buying an amp to fix your speakers. It won't work. Fix the real problem and get speakers that you like.
One thing you may want to try as a test is using the tone on your receiver. If you can't fix the problem, or at least make it a lot better, there's no way an NAD amp (or something similar), can do that much to the sound to make the system work for you.
You did make some mistakes (as we all do) but the above quote is a good call on your part. Don't waste your money on buying an amp to fix your speakers. It won't work. Fix the real problem and get speakers that you like.
One thing you may want to try as a test is using the tone on your receiver. If you can't fix the problem, or at least make it a lot better, there's no way an NAD amp (or something similar), can do that much to the sound to make the system work for you.