Nagra VPS vs ARC PH7 vs Allnic H1500 SE


Hello,

I am in the process of upgrading my phonostage. I have an all tube system based on Tannoy Turnberry SE speakers and Wavac EC-300B amplifier, preamp is a Shindo Aurieges. My phonostage is RCM Sensor Prelude, the only solid state component. I want to go with a tube phonstage. Where I live I can handily find one of these tube phonostages:

1. Nagra VPS
2. ARC PH7
3. Allnic H1500 II SE plus

I like my music to be fast and dynamic without losing the natural flow. I listen to a lot of 50's and 60's music, where flow of melody is as important as dynamics and transparency. Has anyone compared any of these phonostages or listened to them in a known environment ? Please advise with your experiences.

My current cartridge is Lyra Skala
pani
Hi I own a Nagra VPS (on a Nagra VFS platform which I feel is essential for this phono stage).

I've listened to the ARC Ref2 SE phono in another system but it wasn't enough to sway me into a demo at home.

I have had a Allnic H3000v at home. This phono stage is excellent. Little better resolution than the Nagra, better weight on each note, better placement of the instruments in space, however it isn't as transparent in the mids to top end. It's a bit darker in direct comparison from the mids on up. Dynamics and flow seems about the same...now I have heard the Allnic H3000 in 2 systems my friends own. I would NEVER say it was dark in those systems...

The Nagra vs Allnic was in my system using a Lyra Atlas.

If you're looking at sub 10K usd phono stage, the Nagra is very hard to beat. Above 10K I think it's going to have competition from Allnic and others...
Hi there is a new Nagra VPS review posted a few days ago...

http://www.hpsoundings.com/2013/10/review-nagra-vps-valve-phono-preamplifier/