Turnable database with TimeLine


Here is a database showing various turntables being tested for speed accuracy and speed consistency using the Sutherland TimeLine strobe device. Members are invited to add their own videos showing their turntables.

Victor TT-101 with music

Victor TT-101 stylus drag

SME 30/12

Technics SP10 MK2a

Denon DP-45F
peterayer
01-08-14: Richardkrebs
HF Dover
Phase lag is a result of drag, not a cause of it.
Yes, phase lag COULD be a result of stylus drag, but not necessarily exclusively.

As a matter of courtesy, I would ask you to address me correctly as "Dover" which is my name on this forum.

A DC Motor is a simple device. The speed is proportional to voltage input and load. If the load increases then the speed will drop and current will increase. My Sota tt has a simple power supply and DC motor. It has a trim pot for fine tuning speed; but speed will vary as load changes. (A tt with closed loop controller for a DC motor would vary voltage to maintain speed under varying load conditions.) Using the iPhone app I can adjust the speed to within 0.02%- about an order of magnitude off compared to Peter's SME deck. Also, speed drifts on my tt as it warms up so I must let it run for 15-20 minutes before fine tuning the speed. I know the higher end Sota tt's have much more sophisticated motor controllers. I would like to know how they perform in comparison.
Synchronous AC Motors are based on frequency. The rotor of an synchronous AC motor is always following the rotating magnetic field. That is phase lag or slip as Richard mentioned. As the load on an synchronous AC motor increases, phase lag increases. Current draw in the motor will increase which increases torque in order to bring the phase lag back to near zero. The frequency source for a synchronous AC motor can come from the 60Hz AC line or from a seperate frequency generator. Voltage will not change speed on a synchronous AC motor but it will change the amount of torque available to minimize phase lag. (More voltage means more current draw is available.) A closed loop synchronous AC motor controller must vary frequency to adjust speed.
Halcro, My test record that I use for the iPhone app is also flawed. The record hole is off-center so I filed the hole open a bit and I must center it as best as I can on the platter. I get differing Wow&Flutter measurements (between 0.06% down to 002% filtered readings) depending on how well I center the record. My record also has a slight warp and at around 12 seconds into the track the frequency shifts due to this warp. So my overall measurements look better when I start the recording past that warp. I did screen saves on sevaral measurement trials using the iPhone app and finally saw this pattern of speed or frequency shift at the same point every time.
Halcro, that new Victor TT-101/3 arms video is quite impressive. My belt
drive could not do that. I do see the value of testing with and without the arm
being in the groove. Unfortunately, my Timeline is gone so I can't retest or
shoot the video.

Your latest video seems to have much less drift than the first one (with 3 arms
but no music) linked in the OP. I wonder why that is. The drift to the left in
the first one looks like half the length of the Timeline dash so I guessed it is
3/8". The latest video drifts much less, but from about 3:15 in the
video to the end, it is clear that the TimeLine dash is no longer centered on
the blue tack but drifts to the left until about 3/4 of it is to the left of center
and 1/4 is to the right of center.

This is very minimal drift over 5 minutes. Perhaps Tony could calculate the
error if you give him the distance from spindle to blue tack and the drift
distance which looks to be about 1/8" or so.

Syntax did post a video of the thread drive Micro. I'd like to see some of the
modern DD tables like the NVS and also the BD TechDas.