Passive Pre - No Regrets?


I'm interested in hearing from folks who have moved from a high quality active preamp (I'm currently using a CAT SL1 Ulitmate)to a passive preamp and have had no regrets. I'm particularly interested in hearing from those that have switched to a Placette or Sonic Euphoria (the two I'm considering). I'm using a CAT JL2 Amp feeding Merling VSM-MX.
pubul57
"The same with tubes..come on..I know you have a favorite type tube for your equipment... most designers do. Give up the goods!LOL"

Its true. I prefer the tubes that I do because I can get them to be neutral. How neutral? Neutral enough that the state of the art has to evolve to hear the colorations. Even then we find that changing things elsewhere (power supply, wiring, coupling caps etc.) will often deal with it (in effect we still are not hitting the limits!).

I agree that all things make a difference, and I know that creating a system around a coloration will not work in the face of creating a system around no coloration. Synergies in effect do not work.
I know that creating a system around a coloration will not work in the face of creating a system around no coloration. Synergies in effect do not work.

I agree that it is a worthwhile goal to build a component that is completly neutral (straight wire with gain) but since we are all using different speakers that in relative terms are all highly colored, couldn't you end up feeding a speaker with a completely uncolored signal and still have sound that is crap.

As long as we have highly colored speakers further complicated by room interactions, it seems we will always be tweaking the system to color it in a way that compensates for speaker and room colorations.
Yes. It took us years to get around this problem. A big key was working with master tapes! This allowed us to know exactly what the recording really did sound like.
Well,it is official, I love the Placette RVC - in my system it works. I'm finding it hard to justify keeping the CAT for my system and my needs, I've put it up for sale - don't get me wrong the CAT is one of the great preamplifiers,and can obvioulsy do soemtings the RVC cannot (phono, source switching, drive any cables into any loads, etc) and deserves its following, but for single source CD with the right impedance/sensitivity/blah,blah - the RVC is awfully good, especially at its price point (I'm not saying it is good for the price, it is good period - at any price). Of course, I'll be thinking about the active Placette, well, maybe after the CAT is sold.
Congatulations Pubul57!!

As long as we are making announcements I would also point out that my dynamics quest with the passive preamp is over, now I got the dynamics of my previous SS preamp and the transparency of the passive, tweaks helped a lot for this, Ribbon power cables, 2 inch Spruce Wood bases on all my gear, and biamping!!! I now use my passive preamp to drive my mono amps and a Subwoofer....amazing!

Best