Holographic imaging


Hi folks, is the so called holographic imaging with many tube amplifiers an artifact? With solid state one only hears "holographic imaging" if that is in the recording, but with many tube amps you can hear it all the time. So solid state fails in this department? Or are those tube amps not telling the truth?

Chris
dazzdax
Huh!

All I know is that when I hear something or many things, I am hearing them all at the same time. The brain can distinguish between the time arrival between the ears, but if only one ear is working, it cannot distiguish from how far away a sound originates, since the sound waves detected by the ear are simultaneous.
Bob P.
"The speed of sound in air is always varies depending on air pressure, elevation, temperature and humidity."

Atmasphere,

Yes this is true and I beleive I tried to indicate as much with my addition of "(Ignoring long term changes in temperature, humidity etc.)"

I'm assuming that the elevation, temperature etc. is fairly constant in your listening room.

Roger
The bottom line is that your audio system must play to your brain – not your test equipment.
Roger,
That is not the point of the argument. Besides any properly set up rig with decently designed equipment, will do just what you describe or do you seriously maintain, that most of the gear we have at home is but " a poor attempt to recreate a sound event riddled with phase errors" ? Forgive me, if I laugh.
Roger, please don't argue about the speed of sound OK? If you have heat, air conditioning, humidity control or lack of it, weather, what not- the speed of sound will change. You cannot ascribe that as a constant; it is constantly changing.

Phase relationships are maintained through having bandwidth. You got bandwidth, you got imaging. Try turning off the tweeters sometime and see what happens.