FWIW, You've chosen the right tap when you get the sound you enjoy most. Since you have speakers with a nominal 4ohm impedence I'd start with the 4 ohm tap. If your speakers don't have a serious dip in their impedence in the bass you will probably get the best match off the 4 ohm tap. But, if the speaker does have a serious dip in the bass your sound may become enimic and may benefit from using the 2 ohm tap.
Anyway, its likely that there is not perfect fit in any evnt, so just choose what sounds best to you. You won't damage anything.