Negative Feedback a deal killer?


If an amp employees negative feedback is that a deal killer to you. I have had both zero negative feedback and 5db nfb amps and I much prefer the Zero's. I am looking at a Unison 845 amp and it has over 10db nfb. Or should one just listen and shut up.
Your thoughts are appreciated.
Mike
brm1


It all depends whether you like distortion. Appropriate use of negative feedback has been conclusively & scientifically proven to reduce distortion. Therefore, if you like distortion then you will not like negative feedback.
Audiophiles are often fond of attributing all sonic traits of a component to a single issue. It's rather analogous to a car buff assigning everything about an engine's performance to cubic inches.

It is almost never that simple for either audio components or cars. Negative feed back is just like anything else. It can help or it can hurt. It depends on implementation and how it is integrated with all other technical aspects of a design.

That said, I don't know anything about Unison amps, so take a listen if you're truly interested.
From what I gather it depends a whole lot on what speakers you're gonna use with the amp.
That, and if you like distortion :)

I always loved the look of those Unison amps.
Some of the best measuring and worst sounding amps ever made had massive amounts of negative feedback. The Japanese amps of the 70s are the best examples of this, .0001 distortion. It is not that distortion makes an amp sound good, it is what you have to do to reduce it to tiny levels that makes it sound bad. While negative feedback may reduce measured distortion its correlation with sound quality is another matter. A good amp can have no global feedback or a moderate amount. Mine has none and has a considerably higher level of distortion than the vanishing level of distortion amps of the 70s but is a far better sound amp than they were. But intelligent design is everything; we are still searching [after all these years] for either design principals or measurements which will guarantee good sound. Peter Walker , of Quad fame, said years ago that he could build an amp that would look good on every test but that would be unable to play a recognizable tune. Neither design principals nor simple measurements is really going to tell you what an amp sounds like in a given situation. If distortion were the overriding factor then no one would ever buy a tube amp, obviously there are other factors at work.