I don't think another preamp is a very good idea. Why not just add a little attenuation on the input of the preamp "voltage divider". Say 6db to start with.
That would be adding just two resistors on each channel. I don't know the preamp you are using but it may mean just changing the value of two resistors already there. Use good quality resistors and you should be fine.
That would be adding just two resistors on each channel. I don't know the preamp you are using but it may mean just changing the value of two resistors already there. Use good quality resistors and you should be fine.