Balanced / single ended night and day difference


Just for kicks I connected the balanced and unbalanced outputs of my universal player (Marantz ud9004) to an unbalanced and balanced input on my multi channel analog preamp (Theta Six Shooter). I then ran the single ended output through the (single ended only) HT bypass of my 2 channel preamp, so the signal was never fully balanced end to end. Expecting little difference I was in for a shock. Completely different sounding. In a nutshell, RCA is more "dispersed" wider sonudstage, while balanced is more focused (especially vocals are dead in the middle between the mains), I guess better imaging in audiophile speak. Anyone had similar experience? How can this be?
edorr
Wow - When I compared the 2 I heard just the opposite. I preferred the wider sound stage but hated the gain I heard with the balanced cables. I got the single ended.
But keep in mind my balanced is only balanced between source and first preamp. Where does the big difference come from? And yes, balanced has 7db more gain.
I think that a contributing factor to the differences you heard might have been the effects of connecting both sets of outputs of the player to the Theta at the same time, particularly if the player provides signals to both its xlr and rca connectors simultaneously.

First, crosstalk between the two sets of signals may have been occurring. Second, if, as is sometimes the case, the player's rca outputs are driven by the same output stage that drives one of the two xlr polarities, the Theta's 10K input impedance might have been low enough to significantly unbalance both the amplitudes and the impedance levels of the balanced signal pair.

It's also conceivable that some fraction of the signal return currents for the rca connections might take a path through the grounds provided by the xlr connections, and vice versa, affecting low level noise (which can affect ambience perception) and/or crosstalk.

And are you certain that volume levels were precisely equalized during your comparisons?

On the other hand, if you were to just connect one set of cables at a time, you would be faced with the issue of assuring that the equipment was in an equal state of warmup during each part of the comparison, as well as the possibility of aural recollection perhaps becoming less precise.

Getting meaningful and reliable results from this kind of comparison is not necessarily straightforward.

Regards,
-- Al
I connected the XLR and the RCA's to completely separated inputs on the Theta Preamp, and then matched volume levels using an offset. The Marantz source has completely separate circuitry for the 2 channel balanced outputs than for the 2 channel RCA (which are part of the multi channel set of outputs). All I need to do for A/B comparison is switch between inputs on my preamp with the remote.
Good point Al. I forgot to mention when I compared cables at first I had the both connected at the same time. The XRL's were just horrible with the RCA's being an obvious winner. Once I used them separately they both sounded better.

Edorr I have an integrated