2. music
  3. 1300590829

the guess who vs the rock and roll hall of fame

well earlier i posted about the moody blues and got many opinions. most were for inclusion. how about the guess who? my opinion is great songwriting and musicianship/singing. many top 10 songs and most of their classic songs are still fun to listen to. if you had a chance to see the guess who or alice cooper what would the choice be? i vote in. thanks
hotmailjbc
rja's avatar
rja
2,380 posts
 
I agree with Foster9.
What exactly is the criteria for admittance. Doesn't really seem to be any. Pretty much makes the whole thing ludicrous.
Maybe a good idea in the beginning that has unfortunately been diluted into meaninglessness.
montejay
285 posts
 
Audiofeil,
How does one think The Archies, or David Cassidy and The Guess Who are comparable and merit the same musical respect? You may dislike them equally but come on now.

Regards,
hotmailjbc OP
571 posts
 
yes! burton cummings and randy bachman compared to david cassidy and the archies? that's a good one. ha. and everytime the rock n' hall gets it wrong they honor a musician like tom waits so there is hope.
zaikesman
3,017 posts
 
"Let'em all in and make a complete mockery of rock and roll."

The most sensibly appropriate (albeit unintentionally) suggestion made here yet :-)
gawdbless's avatar
gawdbless
1,235 posts
 
Anyone who makes music believes that they are their own hall of fame.
I personally think that the so called 'Hall of Fame' is a load of old bollox.
More to discover