as belated as this may well be...
aS Macdadtexas AND I HAVE BOTH SAID
ITS A MIX. Try as many as you can. The more popular ones will be easier to both get and get rid of if necessary.. usually. Sometimes popular works against you in the Audiogon buy & Try shuffle.
I say again, the BC DAC III is a fine enough place to start..lavry is another. Both camps are engineered by top people and innovators in the digital to analog conversion racket.
Id also disagree with some statements on how upsampled DACs sound. Normally, the higher the sampling rate the easier the top end will be on the ears and the better the ambient retrieval. Resolution and details are a part of the design and materials.
Not the result of oversampling per se.
BTW
. Theres a lot of artificial sounds when the original band isnt right therein
the room.
My 2ch audio system isnt what Id call a warmly romantic affair. I would put it a tick or two onto the warmish side, but more than that I felt it needed two things done better
Bottom end resolution and greater resolution and detail overall, which lends itself to better imaging and gets you closer to reality, or at least the illusion of it.
Wether I use it with SS front to back, or a mix of tubes and SS, (either way T+SS or SS+T), the BC DAC III is NOT anything close to bright sounding. Its about as neutral a device as I think you can get for the money that they are selling for lately around here.
Remember too
bright is in the ear of the beholder, and can be accounted for by many factors. Jitter. Mismatching. Ground loops. Power line artifacts. Poor isolation and/or racks. The recording. The room. Your ears
And so on
The BC D3 allows for a lot of value and flexibility for the $$$. I agree with Macdadtexas it ought to be a nice fit in your system as it is now. If there is resultant glare, hardness, stridency, etc., its not going to be the fault of the BC dac. Look elsewhere about your system.
I listen to all sorts of music. All sorts. I need speed, impact, depth, articulate bass, definition, spot on imaging, and balance in the bandwidth to accommodate all these various genres.
If I were to listen ONLY to Ella and Frank, maybe some other DAC would still be here. Id not wish to hamstring my system though.
Upgrading the system is not a matter of it being a balancing act so much as it should be a step closer to the music itself, while keeping everything on a listenable and musical tilt. Involving. Enjoyable.
Thats where balancing comes into play. Not by compensating for errors or shortdcomings elsewhere.
Ive played your amp or one like it in my home .
its not a bright amp.
The BC D3 might even become a step up over your current preamp as it has remote volume control too.. Add a highface 24 192 if going all PC all the time and youve got a real upgrade on your hands. Add a Oyaide T510 cable, or an XV 2 Ultra for abut $200 +/- and youre in like Flint.
Youll love you CDP all over again too Good luck..