Why do planars have poor bass extension?


I've been wondering about this. Is it because the excursion is limited because of the tension of the diaphragm & low BL limits its excursion?

On a related note, what techniques do companies like Magnepan use to get more bass out of their low-frequency drivers? Do they put bigger magnets in the grid than would be feasible for the midrange? Heavier diaphragms?

Finally if anyone knows a good reference for learning about the TS parameters of planars and if/how such calculations differ from dynamic speakers, that would be awesome!

Thanks all!
sideshowgabe
If the bass area is large enough they can have a lot of bass. My Apogee Duetta Signatures have very impressive bass and the bigger Apogees had even more.
You can have low bass with proper room placement, no piles of equipment and racks, behind, and between the speakers.

Also an adequate sized, but not large room, with not a lot of furniture, and sit in the right spot.

Read "Get Better Sound" by Jim Smith for great info.

My Magnepan 3.6's go down to about 30Hz in the several different rooms I have had them in!

It takes time and careful listening, if you take the effort.
Dipole panels have the same problem with bass as open baffle cone speakers. The technology is less relevant than basic acoutics. As an experiment, try 1' deep plywood "U-frames" on panel speakers.