B&W Nautilus 804's vs Cary 3 Silver Oak Speakers

Have you auditioned the Carys? That may indicate whether they would be either an upgrade or downgrade.

I auditioned them today in the room at the store they sounded fantastic but the room I was in was rather small. The room they would be in at my house would be a basement that’s at least twice as big as the room today. I will more than likely be taking them home this coming week and listening to them with my gear and try to form an opinion. The other thing is the Cary’s are a 2.5-way where the 804’s are a 3-way and I’m concerned that this difference makes a big diference as to whether the Cary’s are an upgrade or not for me. Also maybe I am looking at this difference in the wrong way because the Cary has less speakers. If anyone cares to elaborate on what I will gain or lose between the speakers maybe that would also help me with my decision.

Thanks for the reply it is very much appreciated.

Your biggest upgrade would be to separate your HT from your music system.

You are right that would be an upgrade but I don't have the luxury of having a HT and a Music system so I have to do my best to accommodate the best of both worlds.

Thanks