Yes vicwest and all the re-releases and recent DVD's were done on ATC - some on David Gilmour's setup and some on James Guthrie's setup.
Understandably everyone has a personal preference when it comes to speakers but given the rather specific question and that Pink Floyd (mostly Gilmour) pretty much favour exclusively ATC it would seem that this question has a clear answer. (Assuming Pink Floyd are clear and exacting on what they want in terms of how they sound - a fair assumption I would argue...)
Understandably everyone has a personal preference when it comes to speakers but given the rather specific question and that Pink Floyd (mostly Gilmour) pretty much favour exclusively ATC it would seem that this question has a clear answer. (Assuming Pink Floyd are clear and exacting on what they want in terms of how they sound - a fair assumption I would argue...)