One could just as well posit that the differences in sound among the 3 tables are primarily due to unwanted resonances, either within the turntable mechanism or from the respective plinths, and that slate either dampens the chassis resonance or eliminates the resonance of the factory plinth by replacing it entirely. Once that happens, if you play the same LP on the 3 turntables, you would expect/want them to sound more (but still not exactly) alike. That's what I hear. What favors that hypothesis is that the sound is more neutral. The 3 turntables did not take on a "similar characteristic" so much as they became more neutral to my ears. I suppose you could say "neutral is a coloration". There is no resolution through discussion. That's the beauty of it and the frustration too. I am not saying that slate is the only way to go or even the best way to go. But for me, it's all good.
Best TT plinth material, cost no object
It is said that the best material with which to build a loudspeaker cabinet is LEAD, the second best is concrete and the third is Aluminum. Only the third has been adapted by the industry, for obvious reasons.
Internal and extraneous vibrations need to be dampened or eliminated if sound smearing is to be reduced,
Now to the turntable; remove it from the influence of vibrations, internal vibrations not withstanding, and the vinyl should sound better.
Not all of us can put the turntable outside on the sidewalk where only the elements can affect the sound, but can we make the plinth so HEAVY that we can come close to removing the turntable from the sound room entirely?
Can a lead plinth, not too practical, get us as close as possible to putting the turntable outside, on the concrete walk?
Your thoughts, Ken
Internal and extraneous vibrations need to be dampened or eliminated if sound smearing is to be reduced,
Now to the turntable; remove it from the influence of vibrations, internal vibrations not withstanding, and the vinyl should sound better.
Not all of us can put the turntable outside on the sidewalk where only the elements can affect the sound, but can we make the plinth so HEAVY that we can come close to removing the turntable from the sound room entirely?
Can a lead plinth, not too practical, get us as close as possible to putting the turntable outside, on the concrete walk?
Your thoughts, Ken
- ...
- 43 posts total
- 43 posts total