The thing about the Dead is that they were an experimental band live, so it's going to be hit and miss from song to song and from night to night. Experiments sometimes blow up in your face, but when all goes right it's worth the risk.
As for their studio stuff--yes, the singing is an acquired taste and not everyone's cup of tea, but I think it's a shame if a rock music fan doesn't like American Beauty or Workingman's Dead. I don't think it reflects badly on them, it's just too bad because I believe there's so much there to enjoy. And I feel the same about Sgt. Pepper's, Pet Sounds, Smile and the first two LP's by the Band. I don't put all of these on the same pedestal but they're all extraordinary albums IMO.
Anyway, the Dead, live--always on the edge, rolling the dice and willing to take a percentage of the bad with the good. That's part of what made them special and part of why even fans might not want to hear everything they did. I know the band members owned up that they sometimes stunk so I don't know why any fans should have a hard time admitting it.
As for their studio stuff--yes, the singing is an acquired taste and not everyone's cup of tea, but I think it's a shame if a rock music fan doesn't like American Beauty or Workingman's Dead. I don't think it reflects badly on them, it's just too bad because I believe there's so much there to enjoy. And I feel the same about Sgt. Pepper's, Pet Sounds, Smile and the first two LP's by the Band. I don't put all of these on the same pedestal but they're all extraordinary albums IMO.
Anyway, the Dead, live--always on the edge, rolling the dice and willing to take a percentage of the bad with the good. That's part of what made them special and part of why even fans might not want to hear everything they did. I know the band members owned up that they sometimes stunk so I don't know why any fans should have a hard time admitting it.