LaScala dac with telefunken tubes

I am using a La Scala DAC, and am delighted with it. I am not, however, a tube expert.

FWIW, the reviewer Christian Punter, who hold the Aqua DACs in high regard, had this to say on the thread topic:

As the manufacturer has specially selected the tubes, it is not recommended to experiment with them but if you wanted to, you could. In this case, my experiment was fueled by a recent change in tube complement by the manufacturer. Up until recently, the La Scala was delivered with Telefunken ECC81 tubes but now they started using the Genalex Gold Lion ECC81. The DAC was delivered with the Genalex tubes installed but Marco was so kind to also include a pair of Telefunkens for me to compare.

Well, on this subject I can be very brief: the Genalex tubes are an easy and utter improvement over the Telefunken tubes. The new ones are much more refined and agile as well as more energetic, yet sweeter and airier and very liquid. On top of this, they provide wider soundstaging and clearer positioning of images therein. Yup, this is a very easy call, no ifs, and buts: the new tubes are simply much better.

Note that both tubes mentioned are fundamentally the same (ECC81). In my case, my satisfaction with the sound in stock form (Genalex Gold Lion) is more than high enough to suppress any desire to roll tubes.

For those interested, here’s a link to Punter’s La Scala review, from which the above excerpt was taken:

La Scala

@whipsaw-

I’ve not tried the newer Gold Lion tubes in my La Scala as it was made prior to Aqua making the change from Telefunken. I haven’t experimented with tube voicing in my DAC- as you know there are many opinions and options out there.

I have to say though that after switching to the NOS Tele the difference was immediately noticeable- especially in bass reproduction. It would be interesting to see how the Genelex compares to the NOS tubes I have- maybe I’ll pick up a set.

@designsfx

I would be interested to hear your impressions of any differences between the two. As I mentioned, I am quite inexperienced with tubes, and my current hybrid amp and DAC are my first forays into that world. I don’t doubt that there are differences, but it would surprise me if Aqua had replaced the Telefunken with the Gold Lion without believing that the sound was at least as good.

With regard to the review that I excerpted above, I believe Punter to be a serious reviewer, but I'm sure that some of his reviews are influenced by biases. So I do take his black and white conclusion on this particular topic with a grain or two of salt.

gotta say this is the first time i come across anyone whos listened to TFs to say that they prefer new production gold lion to TF (smooth plates? ribbed?) but hey someone eventually was gonna make a circuit where gold lion was at the top of the the tube chain.